I wrote something on anothers post and decided to make a comment on here aswell. It is to long for one comment, so I am going to write on it in a few posts over time.
Things are easily forgotten over time. A story is passed on, changed slightly to fit a situation, retold, further changed, then retold again. After so many tellings the origional meaning could have changed completly. This is true of any verbal story and we are all guilty of changing a detail or two along the way. First learn to admit that, you are not perfect, I am not perfect. Move past that. After you fight your ego and realise that you too retell things with even a very slight change, be it tone, a word, a phrase, then realise how easy and mindless it seems. Then how unimportant it seems. That is the point, when it seems unimportant we are in the most trouble. Because it seems pointless or meaningless, the small change, we have no problem doing it. This is where things first become lost to time. A simple example using a simple "fact" (must add the following quote, "Every sound theory is baised on unsound assumption"). Keep in mind this is an example, assume there is no doccumentation or people left who fought or had parents or grandparents who did.
During world war two, the United States of America fought Germany.
(Now, a slight change...this will take some time, but watch.)
In World War two, the United States fought Germany.
(still nothing to bad)
World war two was fought between the United States and Germany
(getting a little off, there were more than two in the war but still, both did fight. Lets run with that one a little)
In WWII, the USA fought solely against Germany.
(insert japan aswell and that is where we are at right now. In reality we fought against Germany, Italy, Austria (if I remember right), Japan, and Hungrary. Maybe a few others in there I fotgot about aswell. Now, lets add some assumptions)
The USA defeated Germany in WWII, ending their conflict.
(moving faster)
The USA's defeat of Germany ended WWII
(look, slightly back on track, meaning changed a little though. Lets aim for just plain wrong)
The USA completly defeated its enemy, Germany, in WWII
(way...off... Russia actually beat Germany after the allies decided to allow them first entry into Germany. Assumption of loss time)
Because the USA defeated Germany in WWII, it can be assumed that the USA had better production abilitys and/or tactics.
(uh, oh, an assumption)
The USA had both better tactics and a higher production compacity then Germany during WWII, causing Germany's defeat.
(mixing words and showing an oppinion/assumption as a fact, naughty. Lets make the defeat unimportant)
Germany was screwed during WWII because the USA was better at war.
(a little slang and a slight term change for tactics, what a mess, lets assume more)
The USA was obsessed with war, making it an overwhelming combatant for Germany during WWII
(Getting the hint?)
Because of the agressiveness of the USA, Germany lost WWII.
(enough yet? one more)
The German loss of WWII can be attributed to the USA's agressive policy's.
So, we start with a simple fact, "During world war two, the United States of America fought Germany." And end with "The German loss of WWII can be attributed to the USA's agressive policy's." Note, the initial statement had nothing to do with victors, policies, or even reasons, just a statement. Amazing how it can change.
Something that only has words to back it up can be changed drastically after a few retellings. Simple information can be turned into much more than it ever needs to be. History is lost because of this. Sure, in the example the initial fact is still there but everything else added to it never was. Now, think of some things you see as fact. Here is a simple example. "let he who is without sin cast the first stone." That means do not judge to harshly because we have all done things that are concidered wrong. It is not a free ticket to do whatever you wish. How about thisone, it's a little more obscure. "Do not be bound by tradition" From the same place. Know what it is written as now? "Do not be set in your ways". Same meaning right? Not if you look at it. Being set in your ways means you do the same thing over and over. Tradition is very simular, however, tradition is only once in a great while sometimes, and thoes tend to stick. This is where I will pick up nexttime.
Chatboard (0)